The Best-4 net match is the simplest team format a small golf league can run, and the fairest to a roster that ranges from a 4 to a 20. Each team adds its four lowest net scores for the round; the lower total wins. Here is the format in full, why it suits a league of about twelve, the rule for a day when a team is short, and how Golf Mafia scores it while you play.
The rule
- Every player plays their own ball for eighteen holes and records a gross score.
- Each player's net is their gross minus their league handicap.
- Each team adds its four lowest nets. Only players with a full eighteen holes count.
- The team with the lower total wins the net match. The stake is per player: at $5, every player on the losing team pays $5 to a player on the winning team.
- A tie pays nothing.
Beside it, most two-team leagues play team skins hole by hole, so a round has two bets and a player who is out of one is still in the other.
Why it suits a small weekly league
- Every round counts. Nobody's score is thrown away before the round; the four that count are only known at the end, so the 18-handicapper grinding a 90 may be the fourth score that wins it.
- A blow-up does not sink the team. With six playing and four counting, the worst two rounds a side drop out. A 102 costs its player a skin or two, not the match.
- Absences are survivable. Five playing still gives four to count; a sub fills the sixth.
- It needs no pairings and no brackets. Groups can be mixed across teams, which keeps the skins honest, and the match is still team against team.
- It is one subtraction and one sum. A format a retiree can check on the back of the card is a format nobody argues with.
When a team is short
Both bets need each team to have at least the league's minimum number of players, four as a rule, with a full eighteen holes. Below that the round is void: nobody pays, and every score still counts for the season.
A league may set its minimum lower. Then, when a team has fewer than four players who count, both teams add only as many best nets as the shorter team has: three against three, never three against four, which would hand the short team the bet. The round's numbers say which they used, "Best-3", and the rule itself stays Best-4.
Worked settlement
Team 1's nets: 70, 72, 73, 74, 78, 81, so its Best-4 is 289. Team 2's: 69, 71, 72, 76, 77, 85, Best-4 288. Team 2 wins the net match by a stroke: each Team 1 player pays $5. Skins 5 to 5, nothing on them. The sheet reads "Team 2 wins +$5 · Each Team 1 player pays $5 · Team 2 by 1 stroke."
Variations
Best-3 for a league of eight, by setting the minimum at three. Best-4 of gross for a scratch league, by setting every handicap to zero. Higher stakes on a Mafia day or the season's last round. What does not change is the shape: your own ball, a handful of counting scores a side, settled per player.
How Golf Mafia scores the Best-4
- Live, from every phone. As the groups post scores, the match board shows each team's Best-4 and the four nets that count, marked provisional in amber: a player still on the course is assumed to par the holes left, so the total is honest about being unfinished. "4 of 6 in" says how many have a full round.
- Handicaps as of that round. Each player's net uses the handicap set for that round, which the lineup shows and the history keeps, so a later change never rewrites an old result.
- The settlement, frozen. When the commissioner closes the round, the result is fixed: the winner, the margin, who pays whom, and the round's story in one line ("Closest round of the season"). Everyone gets it in a notification with their own standing.
- Void and short-team rules, built in. A team below the minimum reads void on the board before the round is over; a league with a lower minimum sees "Best-3" where it applied.
