A league format is a promise about what a Tuesday will feel like for six months, so it should be chosen for what it survives, not for what it does on a perfect day with twelve players. Here is what a small-league format has to survive, six formats that do, and the one Golf Mafia scores.
What a format must survive
- Absences. Nine players on a Tuesday is normal. A format that needs exactly twelve is a format for one week in May.
- Blow-ups. Somebody will make a 10. The format should charge them a hole, not the season.
- A 4 and a 20 in the same group. Handicaps have to do real work, or the low players win every week and the high players leave.
- The commissioner's evening. If the format takes an hour of arithmetic, the commissioner lasts two seasons.
- Six months. A format that is fun in April has to be fun in September, when the teams are forty dollars apart.
Six formats that work
- Two teams, Best-4 net plus team skins. Two fixed teams for the season. Each round, each team adds its four lowest net scores and the lower total wins, $5 a player; and the team with the lower gross on each hole wins a skin, $2 a skin on the difference. Survives absences (five still gives four), blow-ups (the worst two a side drop out) and handicaps (nets in one bet, gross in the other). The Best-4 format and team skins in full.
- Points per hole against the field. On every hole, a point to each player you beat on net score. Fair and absorbing, but it needs every card entered hole by hole and it is heavy arithmetic for twelve players by hand.
- Stableford. Points per hole against par on net: one for a bogey, two for par, three for a birdie. Blow-ups cost nothing beyond the hole, which is its point, and the season table is points. Individual, so no team rivalry unless you add one.
- Match-play ladder. Pair the players each week; win and climb. Exciting, and the worst at surviving absences: a missed week is a forfeit, and twelve players make six matches that all have to happen.
- Stroke play with handicaps. Lowest net wins the day, season by average net. The simplest, and the loneliest: a player with a bad front nine has nothing to play for by the turn.
- Ryder Cup weekend. Fourballs, foursomes and singles over two days for points. The right format for the annual trip and the wrong one for a Tuesday.
Side games for any of them
- Skins, team or individual, on every round.
- A pairs better ball once a month: draw the pairs across the teams, each pair keeps its better net on every hole, lowest total wins. The Mafia day.
- Closest to the pin on the par threes, and a birdie pool that pays out at the end of the season.
Choose once
Pick the format in March and keep it until September. A league that changes format in June has two half-seasons and no champion.
What Golf Mafia scores
The first format on the list, exactly as written: two fixed teams, a Best-4 net match and team skins every round, both live from every phone and both settled when the round closes, with the pairs better ball as a side game on any round. The commissioner sets the stakes and the minimum players for a bet, and can switch the team match off for one round (a Mafia-only day: no money, no skins, the scores still count). It does not score points-per-hole, Stableford, ladders or Ryder Cup weekends, and says so rather than scoring them badly.
