Every golf league has the Monday thread: forty messages, three of them answers, one of them a photo of a dog. The commissioner needs eleven yeses or noes by Monday night and a sub for whoever said no. Here is a rule that works on paper, how to handle substitutes, and how Golf Mafia does the asking, the counting and the reminding.
A rule for answering
- Everyone answers, every week, even "no". The commissioner's problem is not the no; it is the silence. A league where silence means yes ends with three players on the first tee.
- A deadline a day before. Answers by Monday night for a Tuesday round, so the groups can be built with the real players.
- "Maybe" expires. A maybe not turned into a yes by the deadline is a no, and a sub is called.
- Changes go to the commissioner, not the thread. One place to look.
How to handle subs
- Keep a standing list, two or three a side, who know the days and want the call. A sub who has played twice is half a regular.
- Give every sub a handicap before they play, even a provisional one, and write it down. A sub playing off nothing is a sub playing off zero. More in league handicaps.
- Decide what a sub counts for. For the team bets, yes: that is the point. For the season's awards, most leagues say regulars only.
- Number them. Regulars 1 to 6 and 10 to 15, subs 7 to 9 and 16 to 18, so the lineup reads at a glance who is who.
The two-hour rule
A reminder two hours before the tee time catches the player who answered yes last Wednesday and forgot. It is the one message every league needs and no thread sends.
How Golf Mafia does it
- Scheduling a round asks the league. The commissioner schedules in five steps (date and course, lineup, groups, formats, review). "Schedule round" sends "Round scheduled · Tue 28 Jul, 8:30 — are you in?" to every member's phone, with the last result, the standings leader and the commissioner's note ("Front nine is cart path only").
- Everyone answers in the app. The Play tab shows the round with three buttons: I'm in, I'm out, Maybe. Answers can change until the round starts, and the same buttons are on the round's own page. A Home Screen widget shows the next round and your answer.
- The commissioner sees who's coming by team: "Team 1 · 5 of 6 in", each player's answer beside their name, the ones who have not answered obvious.
- Subs take the open spots. Edit lineup marks a regular out and adds a substitute, who takes the next sub number for that team; a regular moved across the teams gets a sub number on the other side. Whoever is marked out leaves their group and their Mafia pair; whoever joins goes into the smallest group. Start refuses while a present player has no handicap or no group, and names them.
- Two hours before the tee time, a reminder, personalised with the member's own answer and ending with the commissioner's note.
- Rain? "Move or cancel" under the round changes the day, the tee time or the course, or takes the round off the book. Another day clears everyone's answer and the notification asks again; a new time on the same day keeps them. Everyone is told either way.

What the players see
A notification when a round is scheduled, the three buttons, the reminder, and nothing else to do. A player who turns the "Round scheduled" notifications off still sees the round on the Play tab. The group text can go back to photos of the dog.